We love Amityville (or, as Toomey's calls it on its website, "a quiet little drinking village with a fishing problem"). Enjoy it all with your pup outside on their pet-friendly waterside deck and tiki bar. The menu is limited, but it does the trick, including burgers, salads, and a host of filling appetizers, like nachos, Karli's Loaded Fries, and Baked Stuffed Clams. A great place to relax the day away.