PetsWelcome
What Others Have Said
Amara Cay Resort
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
Excellent Service and Resort.
Excellent service and resort.
Expedia Group verified review
Very small oceanfront, not access, hotel with a nice outside beach bar and pool with various beach seating spots. Small but cute for staying here for 1 night.
Expedia Group verified review
Staff at the bar were upset that I only tipped them $5. Didn’t have to give them anything. They started showing rudeness after the fact I gave them $5. Made faces and talked under there breathe as they made it clear they were talking about me.
Expedia Group verified review
I loved our room, the tiki bar and pool. Staff was friendly and it was a great location. Definitely will stay here again if in the area.
Hotels.com verified review
Wry good stay with helpful friendly staff.
Hotels.com verified review
The resort, while not brand new, is immaculate and well appointed throughout.
Hotels.com verified review
The place was amazing. I enjoyed the time there
Expedia Group verified review
Had a wonderful time in the suite. Staff was kind, friendly, and welcoming. Property was beautiful and well taken care of. Perfect spot for the family.
Expedia Group verified review
Nice beach atea
Expedia Group verified review
Loved our room with Lanai. Bikes were easy to borrow. Beach is lovely. The free boat shuttle between resorts was the highlight, with Mike and Patrick being excellent maritime hosts.
© 2025 petswelcome.com, Inc. Conditions of Use. Please read before using this site.